Oakland Couple Faces $900K Fine for Cutting 38 Protected Oaks Without Permits
Summary
Oakland's City Council is set to vote on fining property owners Matthew Bernard and Lynn Warner nearly $1 million for illegally removing 38 protected trees — mostly coast live oaks — on and around their Claremont Avenue lot between 2021 and 2022. City workers responded to the property five times and issued verbal and written warnings, but the cutting continued without the required permits. The council deadlocked on the penalty in April, with some members questioning enforcement equity, and is expected to revisit the vote Tuesday. If approved, the city may also place a lien on the property.
TSN Take
If you do residential removals, this is the kind of job that can blow back on the contractor too. Before you drop a saw on anything that looks like a native oak, heritage tree, or anything over a certain DBH, pull the local tree ordinance and confirm the homeowner has a valid permit in hand. Get it in writing. 'The owner told me it was fine' is not a defense when the city shows up, and protected-species fines in places like Oakland, Berkeley, and much of the Bay Area can run into six and seven figures fast.
Why It Matters
Tree protection ordinances are getting teeth, and crews who cut without verifying permits risk being pulled into fines, liens, and lawsuits alongside the homeowner. Document everything and walk away from jobs where the paperwork isn't right.
Read the full story at KQED
Read Source ↗